E-2 Visa Denials Rise in 2025: USCIS Tightens Standards for Economic Impact

by

In 2025, USCIS has raised the bar for E-2 investor visa approvals. It’s no longer sufficient for an investor’s business to merely support their own livelihood. The enterprise must now show a measurable economic impact within the United States.

We’ve received many inquiries recently in Requests for Evidence (RFEs) and E-2 visa denials citing one key issue: the “marginal enterprise.” USCIS defines a marginal enterprise as a business that fails to go beyond self sustainability meaning it doesn’t meaningfully contribute to the US economy or create American jobs.

To succeed in 2025, E-2 applicants must demonstrate that their investment will create and sustain US jobs over time, supported by credible financial and operational evidence.

Common Reasons for E-2 Visa Denials and RFEs

Recent E-2 cases reveal several patterns where applications have fallen short of USCIS’s heightened standards:

  • Low Job Creation: Business plans that don’t clearly outline when and how American workers will be hired.
  • Service-Only Models: Online or consulting businesses with no physical presence or tangible assets in the US.
  • Minimal Revenue Projections: Financials that only cover the investor’s own income or living expenses.
  • Generic Operations: Vague descriptions of how the business will operate day to day or manage staff.

These weaknesses often trigger RFEs or outright denials, as USCIS now expects concrete, data backed plans proving the enterprise will grow, employ, and contribute to the US economy.

Case Example: Turning an RFE Into an Approval

A recent client retained our firm to respond to a USCIS RFE that questioned whether his E-2 business demonstrated the potential to expand beyond self sustainability. We revised their business plan to include a clear hiring schedule, detailed daily operations, and proof of physical assets like leased office space and equipment. Within weeks, USCIS approved the petition, recognizing the enterprise’s legitimate potential for US job creation and economic benefit.

What This Means for E-2 Applicants in 2025

E-2 visa scrutiny is at an all-time high. USCIS now demands concrete evidence of economic impact, including plans to hire US workers, operate from a verifiable US location, and generate revenue that benefits more than just the investor.

If your business plan lacks detail, hiring commitments, or credible financial projections, your case is at risk. We can help you prepare, strengthen, and defend your E-2 application to meet the latest adjudication standards.

Get Professional Help With Your E-2 Visa Today

At Messersmith Law Firm, we regularly handle complex E-2 investor visas and can help you:

Develop a USCIS-compliant business plan
Respond to RFEs or overcome marginal enterprise findings
Prove job creation and economic contribution
Maximize your chances of approval

Whether you’re filing your first petition or responding to a recent denial, we offer same-day consultations to get your case back on track.

Email: info@messersmithlaw.com
Call Today: 305-515-0613
Visit: www.messersmithlaw.com

DUI and Green Card: Can a DUI Affect My US Immigration Status?

by

A DUI (Driving Under the Influence) arrest can be terrifying, especially if you’re a green card holder, visa holder, or immigrant applying for permanent residence.

The good news? A single DUI doesn’t automatically mean deportation or green card denial. But depending on your case especially if injuries, drugs, or repeat offenses are involved it can create serious immigration consequences. At The Messersmith Law Firm, we’ve helped immigrants protect their green cards and status after DUI arrests by working closely with both immigration and criminal defense counsel.

Can a DUI Affect My Green Card?

Yes a DUI can affect your green card application or status, depending on:

  • The facts of the arrest (alcohol level, injuries, or drugs)
  • Number of offenses
  • Type of immigration benefit you are applying for
  • How the case was resolved in court

While one minor DUI conviction may not automatically make you inadmissible or removable, it can trigger extra scrutiny by USCIS, ICE, or the immigration court.

How USCIS Views DUI Offenses

In recent years, USCIS has taken a much tougher stance on DUI related cases especially under the Trump and post Trump enforcement guidelines. Common USCIS concerns include:

  1. Moral character issues — DUIs can be viewed as evidence of poor moral character, especially for citizenship (N-400) applications.
  2. Criminal grounds of inadmissibility — DUIs involving drugs, injuries, or multiple offenses may trigger INA §212(a)(2) grounds.
  3. Public safety and national interest — USCIS may deny adjustment of status if the DUI raises public safety concerns.

When a DUI Can Cause Immigration Problems

Not all DUIs are treated equally. Here are situations where a DUI can threaten your green card:

1. DUI with Controlled Substances

If drugs (not just alcohol) are involved, you may be deemed inadmissible under INA §212(a)(2)(A)(i)(II) for violating a controlled substance law even without conviction.

2. Multiple DUI Offenses

Two or more DUI convictions can indicate a habitual problem, causing USCIS to question good moral character.

3. DUI with Serious Injury or Death

If your DUI caused injury or death, it could be charged as a felony or crime involving moral turpitude (CIMT) both serious for immigration.

4. DUI During Pending Immigration Application

If you are waiting for a green card, adjustment of status, or naturalization, a new DUI arrest may cause delays, RFEs, or denials until the case is resolved.

5. DUI and Immigration Detention

Immigrants with pending criminal charges especially those without lawful status risk being detained by ICE after a DUI arrest.

Can I Still Get a Green Card After a DUI?

Yes but a DUI can seriously complicate your green card process, and how you respond right now can make the difference between approval and denial. USCIS and US consulates increasingly treat DUI arrests and convictions as potential signs of inadmissibility, especially if alcohol abuse, multiple incidents, or injury to others are involved. Even a single DUI can trigger additional background checks, medical exams, and delays in your case.

If you’ve had a DUI and are applying for adjustment of status or consular processing, don’t take chances. A misstep in your response or medical documentation can result in denial or permanent inadmissibility.

DUI and Green Card Renewal or Citizenship

If you already have a green card a single DUI will usually not affect renewal but if you apply for naturalization, USCIS may find you lack good moral character especially if the DUI was within the 5 year statutory period before applying for citizenship.

DUI and Waivers Under US Immigration Law

If a DUI triggers inadmissibility due to drug involvement or moral turpitude, you may still be eligible for a waiver under:

  • INA §212(h) – For certain crimes of moral turpitude
  • INA §212(d)(3) – Nonimmigrant waiver for temporary visas
  • INA §212(a)(9)(B)(v) – For unlawful presence combined with a DUI

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q1. Can I be deported for a DUI?

You can be detained or placed in proceedings if you have multiple DUIs, felony DUI, or DUI with drugs or injuries.

Q2. Will a DUI affect my green card interview?

Yes. USCIS will ask about any arrests or convictions.

Q3. Can I travel outside the US after a DUI?

If your DUI makes you inadmissible under immigration law, reentry could be denied.

Q4. Can I apply for a green card with a pending DUI case?

It’s risky. USCIS may delay or deny your application until the criminal case is fully resolved.

Get Legal Help After a DUI — Protect Your Green Card Today

At The Messersmith Law Firm, we’ve successfully helped clients overcome DUI related immigration challenges and secure their green cards. We know how to present your case in the best possible light under immigration law. A DUI doesn’t have to end your American dream but you must act fast. We will analyze your case and develop a plan to protect your green card and immigration future.

Email: info@messersmithlaw.com
Call: 305-515-0613
Visit: www.messersmithlaw.com
Schedule your confidential consultation today to get legal help after a DUI.

EB-1A Green Card for Finance Directors & Senior Financial Analysts

by

If you’re a Finance Director, Senior Financial Analyst, or Fintech Executive driving profitability and financial strategy at a major firm or startup, you may already qualify for a US green card under the EB-1A Extraordinary Ability category. Even without publications or academic awards, your financial leadership, especially if it influences multimillion dollar portfolios, mergers, or investment strategies, can be recognized as extraordinary ability in business under US immigration law.

What Is the EB-1A Extraordinary Ability Green Card?

The EB-1A category is for individuals who have achieved sustained national or international recognition for excellence in their field. It allows self-petitioning and no employer sponsorship or labor certification required. Applicants must meet at least 3 out of 10 USCIS criteria and demonstrate that they’ve risen to the top of their field through evidence of influence, recognition, and achievement. For financial professionals, this means proving a record of significant business impact, high remuneration, and leadership in critical projects.

Why Finance Directors & Senior Analysts Are Strong EB-1A Candidates

Finance professionals routinely make decisions that shape corporate growth, investor confidence, and market stability. When well documented, these roles easily satisfy EB-1A criteria based on quantifiable financial achievements and strategic leadership.

EB-1A CriterionHow Finance Professionals Qualify
Original Contributions of Major SignificanceDesigning investment models, financial systems, or risk frameworks that generated measurable gains or prevented losses.
Leading or Critical RoleOverseeing financial planning, M&A transactions, or capital allocation at a global or regional level.
High Salary or RemunerationCompensation above the 90th percentile in the industry, verified by market data and company documentation.
Published Material or Media RecognitionMentions in financial press, industry reports, or internal company announcements.
Judging the Work of OthersEvaluating projects, budgets, or investment portfolios as part of review boards or executive committees.
Membership in Selective AssociationsMembership in elite professional organizations requiring proven expertise.

EB-1A vs. NIW (National Interest Waiver) for Finance Professionals

Many finance professionals also qualify for the EB-2 National Interest Waiver (NIW), which allows self-petitioning if your work benefits the US economy or financial stability.

CategoryEB-1A (Extraordinary Ability)EB-2 NIW (National Interest Waiver)
FocusIndividual achievement and leadershipUS economic or national benefit
Employer SponsorshipNot requiredNot required
Ideal ForFinance executives, investment leaders, fintech innovatorsAnalysts and financial managers impacting economic growth
Processing TimeFaster (Premium Processing available)Slower (No Premium yet)

Fintech & Quant Finance Professionals: Strong NIW Potential

If you work in fintech, quantitative finance, or blockchain, your innovations often qualify as being in the national interest due to their economic and technological significance. Examples include:

  • Developing AI-based risk or fraud detection systems
  • Creating automated trading or blockchain settlement platforms
  • Leading compliance systems for financial transparency

These can qualify under both EB-1A (extraordinary ability) and EB-2 NIW (national importance) pathways.

How Messersmith Law Firm Helps Finance Professionals Win EB-1A and NIW

At Messersmith Law Firm, we’ve successfully obtained EB-1A and NIW green cards for finance directors, investment analysts, and fintech leaders worldwide. We understand how to translate financial metrics into persuasive immigration evidence.

Our Proven Process:

  • In depth case analysis tailored to financial and corporate roles
  • Strategic evidence mapping linking achievements to USCIS criteria
  • Powerful recommendation letters from financial executives and investors
  • Legal arguments highlighting measurable business impact
  • Premium processing filing for rapid results

Start Your EB-1A or NIW Case Today

Your financial leadership drives growth, stability, and innovation and that qualifies as extraordinary ability in business.

Messersmith Law Firm — Immigration Attorneys for Finance & Investment Professionals
Call 305-515-0613
Email info@messersmithlaw.com
Schedule your consultation today to explore your eligibility for EB-1A or NIW approval.

CBP Detention Lawyer: What to Do If You’re Detained by US Customs and Border Protection

by

Being detained by US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) at the airport or border can be terrifying, especially if your visa is canceled or you’re refused entry. You may be questioned for hours, have your phone searched, or even face expedited removal. If this happens, we can help you respond quickly, communicate with DHS and CBP officers, and protect your right to enter or reapply for a US visa.

What Is CBP Detention?

CBP detention occurs when an immigration officer refers a traveler for secondary inspection at a US port of entry. This usually happens when CBP suspects:

  • Misrepresentation or fraud (INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i))
  • Overstay or violation of visa terms (INA §212(a)(9)(B))
  • Unauthorized work while on a visitor or student visa
  • Security or background flags (INA §212(a)(3)(A)(i),INA §212(a)(3)(A)(ii),INA §212(a)(3)(A)(iii),INA §212(a)(3)(B)
  • Previous immigration or criminal issues (INA §212(a)(2)(A)(i)(I),INA §212(a)(C)(i),INA §212(a)(2)(C)(ii)

During detention, CBP can cancel your visa, deny entry, or issue an expedited removal order under INA §235(b)(1).

What Happens During CBP Secondary Inspection?

CBP officers may:

  • Review your phone, laptop, or social media accounts
  • Interrogate you about your purpose of travel or past visits
  • Pressure you to sign a withdrawal of application for admission or a Form I-860 (Expedited Removal)
  • Cancel your visa with a “CANCELLED WITHOUT PREJUDICE” stamp

Can a CBP Detention Lawyer Help If I’m Still at the Airport?

Yes but time is critical. Our law firm can:

  • Contact the CBP inspection office or duty supervisor
  • Advocate for your release or withdrawal instead of removal
  • Prevent signing documents that admit wrongdoing
  • Arrange for a legal briefing to clarify the issue
  • Protect your eligibility for future U.S. visas

Even if you’ve already been removed, we can still help you reenter legally through waivers or new visa filings.

Common Situations Where CBP Detains Travelers

  • Visa canceled after questioning (especially B1/B2 or F1)
  • Working or volunteering without authorization
  • Returning after overstaying a previous visit
  • ESTA travelers flagged for prior denials or long stays
  • Students on F-1 or J-1 questioned about employment
  • Social media posts suggesting intent to immigrate

In these cases, CBP may accuse you of immigrant intent or misrepresentation, leading to inadmissibility under INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i).

What to Do If CBP Detains You

  1. Stay calm and respectful.
  2. Call us immediately at (305) 515-0613.
    We handle emergency CBP detention cases nationwide even after hours.

FAQ: CBP Detention and Visa Cancellations

Q1. What happens if CBP cancels my visa at the airport?
If CBP cancels your visa, you must return home immediately. However, we can help you reapply or file a waiver to overcome the cancellation.

Q2. What is an expedited removal?
It’s a formal deportation order issued by CBP without a hearing. It can carry a 5 year ban from the US. If a CBP officer mistakenly issued a five year bar against you, we can challenge the determination and have the bar removed. Our firm has successfully achieved this result for many clients in similar situations.

Q3. Can I get a visa again after expedited removal?
Yes, it’s possible. However, if you were also found inadmissible under INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i) (fraud or misrepresentation) or INA §212(a)(6)(E) (alien smuggling), you will need a 212(d)(3) nonimmigrant waiver, another applicable waiver, or to have those inadmissibility findings formally removed from your record before you can obtain a new visa.

If you were deemed inadmissible under INA §212(a)(3)(A)(i), §212(a)(3)(A)(ii), or §212(a)(3)(A)(iii) (security-related grounds), no waivers are available.

However, if these determinations were made in error, which happens more often than people realize, our firm can challenge the finding and work to remove it from your record, helping you regain eligibility for a US visa.

Q4. Can CBP detain a US visa holder overnight?
Yes. CBP can hold travelers in secondary inspection or a local detention facility until they’re placed on a return flight.

Q5. How long does CBP detention last?
Usually a few hours but in complex cases it can last overnight or longer until a supervisor decides your case.

Get Immediate Legal Help Today

We work directly with CBP, the US Department of State, and consular officers to correct records and restore eligibility for entry. If you or someone you know is detained by CBP, refused entry, or had a visa revoked at the airport, contact us right now. Every minute counts fast legal action can change the outcome.

Call (305) 515-0613
Email info@messersmithlaw.com
Same-Day Consultations Available

We have successfully helped travelers released from CBP detention and reentered the US legally even after expedited removal.

EB-1A Green Card for Directors of Engineering & Software Engineering Managers

by

In the fast evolving world of technology, Directors of Engineering and Software Engineering Managers play a critical role in shaping innovation, driving large scale systems, and leading global teams. If you hold one of these titles, you may qualify for the EB-1A (Extraordinary Ability) or NIW (National Interest Waiver) green card. No publications or PhD required. This guide explains how senior technology professionals can successfully obtain a US green card through leadership, innovation, and measurable impact, not just academic achievements.

What Is the EB-1A Green Card?

The EB-1A category is designed for individuals who have reached the top of their field in science, technology, business, or the arts. Unlike most employment based categories, you don’t need a job offer or employer sponsorship. To qualify, you must meet at least three of ten criteria, such as original contributions, leadership, high salary, or recognition by peers, and show sustained national or international acclaim.

Why Directors of Engineering Qualify for EB-1A

Software engineering leaders often meet multiple EB-1A criteria without traditional academic credentials.
Here’s how top engineers and managers demonstrate extraordinary ability:

EB-1A CriterionHow a Director of Engineering or Manager Qualifies
Original Contributions of Major SignificanceDeveloping or deploying large scale technologies used by millions of users, improving system efficiency, or introducing patented algorithms.
Leading or Critical RoleManaging global teams or leading high stakes projects at companies like Google, Amazon, Meta, or fast growing startups.
High Salary or RemunerationEarning top tier compensation packages that exceed the 90th percentile for your role according to US Department of Labor data.
Judging the Work of OthersServing as a technical interviewer, code reviewer, hackathon judge, or reviewer for internal innovation programs.
Membership in Associations Requiring Outstanding AchievementInvited memberships in selective tech or leadership organizations.
Media or Industry RecognitionBeing featured in company announcements, press releases, or industry blogs about your leadership or innovation.

Common EB-1A Evidence for Engineering Leaders

Even if you lack academic publications, you can prove “extraordinary ability” through real world, outcome-based documentation, such as:

  • System architecture diagrams or patent filings.
  • Evidence of leading successful product launches.
  • Documentation showing your code, framework, or system is widely adopted.
  • Organizational charts showing your leadership position.
  • Performance evaluations highlighting innovation and impact.
  • Salary data and offer letters proving above market earnings.
  • Recommendation letters from senior executives, CTOs, or tech peers.

What About the NIW (National Interest Waiver)?

If you don’t yet qualify for EB-1A, the National Interest Waiver may be an excellent alternative. This green card category also allows self-petitioning, no employer sponsorship required, and focuses on the national importance of your work.

How Software Engineering Managers Qualify for NIW:

  • Building or managing infrastructure critical to cybersecurity, AI, or national data systems.
  • Creating technologies that improve productivity, reduce costs, or enhance safety.
  • Leading initiatives with broad economic or social benefit to the US.
  • Contributing to emerging industries such as fintech, AI, or green tech.

NIW petitions can succeed even without international awards or citations when you show substantial merit, national importance, and that your work benefits the U.S.

Real World Success Story

A Director of Engineering at a global fintech company came to our firm after being told he didn’t qualify because he had no publications. We built his EB-1A petition around:

  • His leadership of a multi-region payments platform handling billions in transactions,
  • His patent on data optimization, and
  • Salary evidence showing he was among the top 5% of earners in his industry.

USCIS approved the petition in nine days under premium processing.

How Messersmith Law Firm Can Help

We’ve helped thousands of clients , including engineering managers, directors, and startup founders, secure EB-1A and NIW green cards. We know how to translate technical leadership into legal evidence that USCIS understands.

Our services include:

  • Evaluating your eligibility for EB-1A or NIW
  • Building a strong, custom legal argument for extraordinary ability
  • Drafting recommendation letters from executives and peers
  • Preparing your petition and evidence package for maximum approval success
  • Filing with USCIS and handling RFEs or NOIDs if issued

Take the Next Step

If you are a Director of Engineering, Software Engineering Manager, or senior technical leader, now is the time to explore your EB-1A or NIW eligibility.

  • Call us at 305-515-0613
  • Email info@messersmithlaw.com
  • Schedule your consultation today — and let’s build your path to a U.S. green card.

H-1B Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR) Due to Work Location Violation or Unlawful Presence

by

If your employer or you personally received a Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR) on your H-1B petition, especially for work location violations or unlawful presence, you are facing a serious immigration issue that can jeopardize your job, status, and future green card eligibility.

The good news? Many H-1B revocations can be successfully challenged with the right legal strategy and evidence but timing is critical. Below are the most frequently asked questions (FAQs) about H-1B NOIRs, worksite compliance, and unlawful presence, and how our attorneys can help protect your status.

What Is an H-1B Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR)?

A Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR) is a letter from USCIS informing your employer that it intends to revoke an already approved H-1B petition. This happens when USCIS later believes the petition was approved in error or that the employer or beneficiary violated H-1B conditions.

Common triggers for a NOIR include:

  • Change in work location without a new LCA (Labor Condition Application)
  • Third party placement without control or supervision
  • Unlawful presence due to status lapse or withdrawal
  • USCIS site visit inconsistencies
  • Misrepresentation in job duties or worksite details

Why Does USCIS Revoke H-1B Petitions for Work Location Violations?

USCIS regulations require that the LCA and H-1B petition match the actual job location. If an H-1B worker moves to a new city or worksite without filing an amended H-1B petition, it’s considered a material change and a regulatory violation. This can lead to:

  • Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR)
  • Finding of unlawful presence
  • Loss of H-1B status
  • Denial of future extensions or green card filings

Even a small change such as working remotely in another city can trigger a compliance issue if no amendment was filed.

What Does “Unlawful Presence” Mean in an H-1B Context?

If USCIS finds your H-1B petition was invalid (for example, due to a location violation), your status may be considered void retroactively, meaning you could have been unlawfully present in the U.S. without realizing it. Unlawful presence carries harsh penalties:

  • 180+ days (but less than 1 year) = 3 year reentry bar
  • 1 year or more = 10 year reentry bar

This is why it’s critical to act quickly if you’ve received a NOIR or suspect an H-1B violation.

How Should Employers Respond to an H-1B NOIR?

If your company receives a NOIR, it must respond within 30 days with documentary evidence refuting USCIS’s claims. A well drafted legal response can often prevent revocation and preserve both the employer’s compliance record and the employee’s lawful status.

Can the Employee Respond Directly to a NOIR?

Usually, the petitioning employer must respond to the NOIR, not the employee. However, the H-1B employee should coordinate closely with an immigration attorney, as a revoked petition can directly affect their ability to stay or change employers. If your employer lacks experience handling a NOIR, or is unwilling or slow to act, we can help ensure your immigration interests are protected.

What Are the Consequences of an H-1B Revocation?

If USCIS revokes the petition, the consequences may include:

  • Immediate loss of H-1B status
  • Accrual of unlawful presence
  • Denial of change of employer petitions
  • Issues with future H-1B cap exemptions
  • Problems with green card processing (especially I-140 or I-485)

How Can We Help With an H-1B NOIR for Worksite Violation?

We can:

  • Analyze the NOIR and identify weaknesses in USCIS’s reasoning
  • Prepare a legal brief and collect evidence of compliance
  • Communicate with USCIS officers on your behalf
  • Negotiate or file a new H-1B petition to maintain lawful status
  • Argue against unlawful presence determinations

Our firm has successfully handled NOIRs caused by remote work, client site projects, and inter company transfers where USCIS initially claimed violations.

What If I Already Accrued Unlawful Presence After a Revocation?

If your H-1B petition was revoked and you’ve already started accruing unlawful presence, you still have options but time is critical. Unlawful presence can lead to devastating immigration consequences, including:

  • A 3 year bar from reentry if over 180 days, or
  • A 10 year bar if over one year.

However, our experienced attorneys have helped clients avoid these bars and regain lawful status by taking immediate legal action. Every day you wait increases your legal risk and can make recovery more difficult.

We Can Help You Respond to a H-1B NOIR or Prevent Revocation

If you or your employer received an H-1B Notice of Intent to Revoke, especially related to work location or unlawful presence, do not ignore it. You have only 30 days to respond, and one mistake can lead to revocation, deportation, or years of immigration delays.

Call us immediately at 305-515-0613 or email info@messersmithlaw.com. Our experienced immigration lawyers have helped hundreds of professionals and employers defend H-1B approvals and avoid unlawful presence findings.

Can Startup Founders Qualify for EB-1A? [Yes — Here’s How]

by

If you’re a startup founder, CEO, or entrepreneur wondering whether you can qualify for an EB-1A Extraordinary Ability Green Card, the answer is YES so long as your achievements demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim. Many founders think EB-1A is only for scientists or PhDs but that’s a myth. In recent years, USCIS has approved EB-1A green cards for tech founders, investors, product innovators, and startup executives who can show significant impact and leadership in their field.

Here’s what you need to know and how to build a winning EB-1A petition as a startup founder.

What Is the EB-1A Green Card for Extraordinary Ability?

The EB-1A green card is a first-preference immigrant visa for individuals who have risen to the very top of their field in business, science, arts, education, or athletics. It allows you to self-petition (no employer sponsor required) and offers fast processing, often leading to green card approval in months.

Startup founders qualify if they can show:

  • Original contributions of major significance in business or technology,
  • Leadership or critical role in a distinguished organization, and
  • Evidence of recognition at a national or international level.

Can Entrepreneurs and Startup Founders Really Get EB-1A?

Absolutely. Startup founders can and do qualify for EB-1A. USCIS recognizes entrepreneurial innovation and leadership as extraordinary ability if you can prove your impact, influence, and success.

Our firm has obtained EB-1A approvals for:

  • Founders who raised venture capital or government innovation grants,
  • Startup CEOs featured in media and tech publications,
  • Founders with patents, awards, or unique technology, and
  • Entrepreneurs who built startups with national or international reach.

What EB-1A Criteria Fit Startup Founders Best?

USCIS has 10 criteria for EB-1A and you need to meet at least three, but we recommend building evidence for four to six. Here are the most common EB-1A criteria that apply to startup founders:

  1. Original Contributions of Major Significance
    • Innovative technology, product, or business model that changed an industry or attracted large user adoption.
  2. Leading or Critical Role in a Distinguished Organization
    • CEO, co-founder, or key executive role in a company recognized for excellence, funding, or market disruption.
  3. Published Material About You or Your Company
    • Media coverage in outlets like TechCrunch, Forbes, or Business Insider highlighting your achievements.
  4. High Salary or Equity Compensation
    • Earning or equity valuation above industry average.
  5. Judging the Work of Others
    • Participation as a startup competition judge, accelerator mentor, or peer reviewer.
  6. Membership in Prestigious Organizations
    • Acceptance into selective startup programs

What if I Don’t Have Awards or Publications?

You can still qualify. USCIS allows startup founders to meet EB-1A criteria without academic publications or formal awards. If your business impact, innovation, and leadership clearly demonstrate distinction.

For example:

  • Founders with venture capital backing or major partnerships can satisfy multiple criteria.
  • Revenue growth, industry adoption, or innovation patents often meet the “original contribution” requirement.

How Long Does EB-1A Take for Founders?

With premium processing, USCIS can decide your EB-1A petition within 15 calendar days. Once approved, you can:

  • Adjust status to a green card inside the U.S., or
  • Apply for an immigrant visa abroad.

Founders often use EB-1A to move from startup visas (O-1, H-1B, or E-2) to permanent residency.

How Can an Immigration Lawyer Help Startup Founders Win EB-1A?

Our office will:

  • Identify which criteria best fit your background,
  • Help you build a strong case,
  • Draft persuasive legal arguments and letters of support, and
  • Structure your business achievements to meet USCIS’s extraordinary ability standard.

Our firm has successfully represented tech founders, venture-backed entrepreneurs, and startup executives in Silicon Valley, New York, and worldwide.

Ready to Build Your EB-1A Case?

If you’re a startup founder or entrepreneur with proven success, innovation, or leadership, you may already qualify for the EB-1A extraordinary ability green card. Don’t risk a denial with a weak or incomplete filing. Let us craft a powerful EB-1A strategy for you. Contact us today at 305-515-0613 or email info@messersmithlaw.com to schedule a consultation.

We’ve helped countless entrepreneurs achieve EB-1A approval and we can help you too.

INA §212(a)(6)(C)(ii): False Claim to US Citizenship — FAQs and Legal Solutions

by

Few immigration violations are as serious as a false claim to US citizenship. Under INA §212(a)(6)(C)(ii), any noncitizen who falsely represents themselves as a US citizen for any immigration or benefit purpose is permanently inadmissible to the United States. This is a lifetime bar with very limited exceptions. If you’ve been accused of a false claim to citizenship, it’s critical to understand the law and your options. Below are the most common FAQs about INA 212(a)(6)(C)(ii) and strategies to fight it.

What Is INA §212(a)(6)(C)(ii)?

INA §212(a)(6)(C)(ii) states that any noncitizen who falsely represents themselves as a US citizen for any purpose under immigration law, or to obtain a federal or state benefit, is permanently inadmissible.

What Are Examples of False Claims to US Citizenship?

  • Checking the “US citizen” box on a Form I-9 for employment eligibility.
  • Claiming to be a US citizen at the border to gain entry.
  • Registering to vote or actually voting in a US election.
  • Using a US passport, birth certificate, or Social Security number fraudulently.
  • Applying for federal student loans restricted to citizens.

Is 212(a)(6)(C)(ii) a Lifetime Ban?

Yes. Unlike many other grounds of inadmissibility, a false claim to citizenship generally results in a permanent, lifetime bar from entering or staying in the US.

Are There Any Exceptions to 212(a)(6)(C)(ii)?

There are very limited exceptions, including:

  1. False claims made before September 30, 1996 (when the law took effect).
  2. Claims made by minors who can show they did not understand the nature of the false claim.
  3. Claims made by mistake or without willful intent. For example, checking the wrong box accidentally without intent to deceive.
  4. Certain cases involving US citizen parents where the applicant reasonably believed they were a US citizen.

Can I Get a Waiver for 212(a)(6)(C)(ii)?

Generally, no immigrant waiver exists for a false claim to US citizenship. This makes it one of the toughest immigration violations. However, legal strategies may include:

  • Challenging the accusation by showing you never made the false claim.
  • Proving the alleged misrepresentation was not material or not “willful.”
  • Arguing that the exception for minors or mistaken claims applies.

What Are the Consequences of a False Claim to US Citizenship?

  • Green Card Denial or Rescission if USCIS finds you falsely claimed citizenship.
  • Visa Denial at U.S. consulates.
  • Removal Proceedings if discovered after you’ve entered the US.
  • Permanent Bar to adjustment of status or naturalization.

Can I Ever Become a US Citizen After a False Claim?

In most cases, no. A false claim to US citizenship makes you permanently ineligible for naturalization unless you can prove an exception applies.

Should I Hire a Lawyer If I’m Accused of 212(a)(6)(C)(ii)?

Yes and immediately. This is one of the most unforgiving grounds of inadmissibility. An experienced immigration attorney can:

  • Review your records to confirm whether USCIS’s allegation is accurate.
  • Gather evidence to prove an exception applies.
  • Challenge the finding in waiver requests, motions, or appeals (where possible).
  • Defend you in request for more evidence (RFE), Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID), Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR) and Notice of Intend to Rescind (NOIR).

Your Path to Approval Starts with the Right Legal Team

A false claim to US citizenship under INA 212(a)(6)(C)(ii) is a life-changing allegation that can result in a permanent bar to US immigration. But not all cases are clear cut. Exceptions and legal defenses may apply. If you’ve been accused of making a false claim to US citizenship, don’t wait. Contact our office at 305-515-0613 or email info@messersmithlaw.com today. Our attorneys have successfully defended clients in complex misrepresentation cases and can help explore your best legal options.

Top 5 Reasons EB-1 Green Card Applications Get Denied And How to Avoid Them

by

The EB-1 Green Card is one of the fastest and most prestigious US immigration options for individuals with extraordinary ability, multinational executives, or outstanding professors and researchers. But despite strong qualifications, many EB-1 petitions are denied. Understanding the top reasons EB-1 green card applications get denied and how to avoid them can significantly increase your chances of success.

Below are the most frequently asked questions (FAQs) about EB-1 denials and strategies to prevent them.

What Are the Top 5 Reasons EB-1 Green Card Applications Get Denied?

  1. Weak Evidence of Extraordinary Ability
    • USCIS requires detailed documentation. Simply having achievements is not enough, they must be proven with strong evidence such as press articles, contracts, or industry recognition.
  2. Failure to Meet Three Criteria
    • For EB-1A, you must meet at least three of the ten criteria (judging, membership, high salary, leading role, etc.). Many applicants fail to document them correctly.
  3. Problems with the Final Merits Determination
    • Even if you meet three criteria, USCIS applies a final merits analysis. If they don’t believe your career demonstrates sustained acclaim, they may deny the case.
  4. Inconsistencies or Misrepresentation
    • Discrepancies in resumes, employment history, or prior visa applications can trigger INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i) misrepresentation findings and result in denial.
  5. Poor Legal Strategy or Self-Filing
    • Many applicants file pro se (without an attorney) and underestimate how USCIS scrutinizes EB-1 cases. Weak legal arguments or disorganized evidence presentation often lead to denials.

Can I Reapply After an EB-1 Denial?

Yes. Many applicants succeed on a second filing, especially when they work with an experienced EB-1 lawyer. A denial does not bar you from reapplying, but you must strengthen your evidence and address USCIS concerns.

How Can I Avoid an EB-1 Denial?

  • Work with an experienced EB-1 attorney.
  • Collect comprehensive evidence for at least 4–5 criteria (not just 3).
  • Prepare a strong legal brief explaining why your work has national or international significance.
  • Ensure all documents are consistent with your past immigration history.
  • Anticipate USCIS’s final merits determination and build arguments accordingly.

What If My EB-1 Was Already Denied?

You have options:

  • Motion to Reconsider (MTR) if USCIS made an error in applying the law.
  • Motion to Reopen (MTR) if you have new evidence.
  • Appeal to the AAO if the denial was based on a misinterpretation.
  • Refiling a stronger petition with additional evidence.

Should I Hire a Lawyer for My EB-1 Green Card?

Yes. EB-1 is one of the most heavily scrutinized green card categories. USCIS officers are trained to challenge evidence, and without a carefully crafted petition, even qualified applicants get denied. we can:

  • Identify the strongest criteria for your case.
  • Organize evidence to meet USCIS standards.
  • Draft persuasive legal arguments.
  • Prevent mistakes that often lead to denial.

Don’t Risk a Denial. Let Us Fight for Your Green Card

The EB-1 green card offers a fast path to permanent residence, but denials are common when petitions lack strategy or strong evidence. By understanding the top 5 reasons EB-1 applications get denied and working with an experienced EB-1 lawyer you can significantly improve your chances of approval.

If you’ve received a denial or are preparing your EB-1 petition, contact us today at 305-515-0613 or email info@messersmithlaw.com. We have successfully helped thousands of clients secure EB-1 approvals, and we can help you too.

INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i): Misrepresentation in US Immigration FAQs and Solutions

by

Being found inadmissible under INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i) is one of the most serious challenges in US immigration law. This section of the Immigration and Nationality Act applies when USCIS or the Department of State determines that a person willfully misrepresented a material fact in order to obtain a visa, green card, or other immigration benefit.

If you or a loved one has been accused of misrepresentation or fraud under INA 212(a)(6)(C)(i), it’s critical to understand what this law means and how to fight it. Below are the most common FAQs about this ground of inadmissibility.

What Is INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i)?

INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i) states that any person who, by fraud or willfully misrepresenting a material fact, seeks to procure (or has procured) a visa, admission into the US, or any immigration benefit, is inadmissible for life. In short: If USCIS finds you lied or concealed important information, you may be permanently barred from getting a visa or green card.

What Counts as “Misrepresentation”?

Misrepresentation can include:

  • Falsifying information on Form DS-160, DS-260, or I-485
  • Using fake employment letters, bank records, or academic documents
  • Claiming a false marital status or family relationship
  • Failing to disclose prior visa denials, deportations, or immigration violations
  • Listing fraudulent employment (such as “Findream” or other fake OPT employers)
  • Misrepresenting intent at a visa interview (saying you’re visiting but actually planning to stay permanently)

What Is a “Material Fact”?

A fact is considered material if it would have influenced USCIS or a consular officer’s decision to grant or deny your visa or green card.

Example:

  • Forgetting to list a minor traffic ticket is usually not material.
  • Concealing prior unlawful presence or misrepresenting employment is material, and can trigger 212(a)(6)(C)(i).

Is 212(a)(6)(C)(i) a Lifetime Ban?

Yes. A finding of misrepresentation under this section creates a lifetime bar from entering the US or obtaining a green card. However, we have successfully helped many people overcome it through legal challenges or waivers.

How Can You Overcome INA 212(a)(6)(C)(i)?

Options may include:

  1. Challenge the Finding
    • If USCIS or the consulate made a mistake, we can argue that no misrepresentation occurred or that the fact was not material.
  2. I-601 Waiver of Inadmissibility
    • If you have a U.S. citizen or permanent resident spouse or parent, you may apply for a fraud/misrepresentation waiver by showing extreme hardship to your qualifying relative.
  3. I-601A Provisional Waiver (if unlawful presence also applies)
    • In some cases, you may need both a fraud waiver and unlawful presence waiver.
  4. Reopening or Appealing Your Case
    • If the finding was incorrect or based on weak evidence, we can fight it through motions, appeals, or rescission challenges.

What Are Common Examples of 212(a)(6)(C)(i) Cases?

  • OPT Fraud: A student listed fake companies (like Findream) as OPT employers. USCIS alleged misrepresentation, but with legal evidence, some applicants have kept their green cards.
  • Marriage Fraud Allegations: A green card holder accused of entering a sham marriage but later proved the relationship was bona fide.
  • Visa Application Errors: Applicants denied for failing to disclose prior overstays or visa denials.

Can I Still Get a Green Card With 212(a)(6)(C)(i)?

Yes, but only if you successfully fight the finding or obtain a waiver. Without legal help, most applicants will face denial or rescission of status.

Should I Hire a Lawyer for 212(a)(6)(C)(i) Issues?

Absolutely. This is one of the most complex and high-stakes areas of immigration law. An experienced attorney can:

  • Review your case to see if USCIS’s finding is valid.
  • Gather evidence to challenge the misrepresentation.
  • Prepare a hardship waiver application if needed.
  • Defend you in rescission or removal proceedings.

Your Path to Approval Starts with the Right Legal Team

Being accused of fraud or misrepresentation under INA 212(a)(6)(C)(i) is overwhelming, but it does not have to end your immigration journey. With the right legal strategy, evidence, and waiver applications, many people successfully keep or obtain their U.S. green card. If you’re facing a 212(a)(6)(C)(i) misrepresentation finding, contact us today at 305-515-0613 or email info@messersmithlaw.com. We have successfully fought these cases and helped clients preserve their lawful status in the US.